TradeTally

VAT Flat Rate Scheme: Is It Worth It for Tradespeople?

TradeTally

VAT Flat Rate Scheme: Is It Worth It for Tradespeople?

The VAT Flat Rate Scheme lets you pay HMRC a fixed percentage of your VAT-inclusive turnover instead of working out the difference between the VAT you charge and the VAT you pay on materials. It suits tradespeople who sell mostly their own time and buy few materials, and who want simpler VAT paperwork. It costs you money if you buy a lot of materials, or if HMRC classes you as a limited cost business, because you cannot reclaim VAT on purchases. Compare both methods on your own figures before you join.

TL;DR

Table of Contents

How the Flat Rate Scheme works

On standard VAT, you charge 20% on your invoices (output tax), reclaim the VAT on your purchases (input tax), and pay HMRC the difference. The Flat Rate Scheme replaces that sum with one multiplication.

Standard VAT and flat rate calculation comparison

You keep invoicing your customers at the normal rate. At the end of the VAT period you add up your VAT-inclusive turnover and multiply it by your flat rate percentage. That is what you pay HMRC. Whatever you collected from customers above that amount is yours to keep.

HMRC’s own example is a photographer who bills £1,000 plus 20% VAT, so £1,200 in total. At an 11% flat rate, they pay 11% of £1,200, which is £132. The percentage is applied to the VAT-inclusive figure, not the net one. That catches people out when they compare the scheme with standard VAT.

The official scheme guidance lists the main benefits as simpler record keeping, rates that are lower than the standard rate, and easier cash flow management. You do not need to record every purchase invoice to work out what you owe. Because the flat rates are averages with an allowance for input tax built in, you can also pay more than you would on standard VAT. Which way it falls depends on your costs.

What counts as turnover

Flat rate turnover includes your VAT-inclusive sales at standard, reduced and zero rates, plus exempt income such as rent. It leaves out private income, bank interest, other non-business income, and sales of capital items where you claimed the input tax. The same guidance has the full list.

Who can join, and when you must leave

You can join if you are VAT registered and expect your VAT taxable turnover to be £150,000 or less, excluding VAT, over the next 12 months. Most sole traders are well inside that.

There are exclusions. You cannot join if, in the relevant period, you:

You have to leave if, on the anniversary of joining, your turnover for the last 12 months was more than £230,000 including VAT, or you expect it to be in the next 12 months. You must also leave if you expect your income in the next 30 days alone to go over £230,000 including VAT. You can leave voluntarily at any time by writing to HMRC, though you cannot rejoin for 12 months after leaving. Treat joining as a choice you will live with for at least a year.

The scheme is only for VAT-registered businesses. The registration threshold is £90,000 of taxable turnover, and you can register earlier if you want to. If you are unsure when you must register, our guide to the VAT registration threshold for tradespeople covers it.

Finding your flat rate percentage

Your percentage depends on the sector that best describes what your business will be doing in the coming year. HMRC publishes the list, and the rates run from 4% to 14.5% depending on trade sector, before the limited cost rule is applied. A few that matter to tradespeople, from the GOV.UK rate table:

Sector Flat rate
General building or construction services 9.5%
Labour-only building or construction 14.5%
Computer and IT consultancy or data processing 14.5%
Management consultancy 14%
Retailing not listed elsewhere 7.5%
Any other activity not listed elsewhere 12%

Two rules help you pick the right line:

  1. Match the sector that fits best. Use the list first, then the composite sectors, then the “not mentioned elsewhere” sectors. Use “any other activity” only if nothing else fits.
  2. One rate only. If your work spans several sectors, apply the rate for your main activity by turnover. You do not split your turnover or use more than one percentage. HMRC’s example is a taxi business that also does car repairs: it applies the taxi rate to everything.

You also get a 1% discount in your first year as a VAT-registered business, so a 9.5% rate becomes 8.5% for that year.

The limited cost trader rate

This is the rule that decides whether the scheme works for many sole traders. You are a limited cost business if your spend on goods is less than 2% of your turnover, or more than 2% but less than £1,000 a year. A limited cost business pays 16.5% whatever its sector. The rate was introduced from 1 April 2017 to stop abuse of the scheme, and it was aimed at businesses with very few costs.

The discount stacks: in your first year a limited cost business pays 15.5%.

A self-employed tradesperson who only supplies labour, and whose customers buy the materials, can easily fall under the 2% line. If that is you, assume 16.5% when you run the numbers. Goods here means things you buy for the business to use or resell. HMRC keeps a specific definition, and you must keep a record of your goods spend with your VAT account.

The limited cost trader rate

Flat rate or standard VAT: two worked examples

The examples below use round, made-up figures to show the method. They are not forecasts for your business. Swap in your own quarter.

Example 1: a materials-heavy plumber

A plumber invoices £40,000 net in a year, so £48,000 including VAT. They buy £8,000 of materials, which is £9,600 with VAT.

Here the scheme leaves £1,840 more in the plumber’s pocket. Their goods spend is well above the limited cost line, so the 9.5% rate holds. This is the profile the scheme was built for: reasonable materials, but not enough input VAT to beat a low flat rate.

Example 2: a labour-only trade

A self-employed tradesperson invoices the same £40,000 net (£48,000 gross) but buys only £500 of goods. That is under 2% of turnover, so they are a limited cost business.

The scheme costs slightly more than standard VAT, and you still lose the VAT on any van, tool or equipment purchases that standard VAT would have let you claim. You gain only simpler paperwork. Dropping to the 15.5% first-year rate would change the sum, which is why you should rerun it each year.

What the examples tell you

The more VAT you pay on materials and equipment, the more standard VAT favours you. The scheme also does not suit you if you regularly get repayments from HMRC, because the scheme is not designed for that position. On the scheme you cannot reclaim VAT on purchases, apart from a single capital asset costing £2,000 or more including VAT. Check the official guidance for the exact rule before relying on it.

A quick test:

  1. Take the last four VAT quarters.
  2. Add up VAT-inclusive sales. Multiply by your flat rate (check it against the limited cost test).
  3. Add up VAT you reclaimed on purchases and subtract it from the VAT you charged.
  4. Compare the two totals. If standard VAT is within a few hundred pounds, the simpler records may be worth the difference.

Records, returns and Making Tax Digital

The scheme does not mean fewer returns. You still file VAT returns through compatible software, and the VAT Notice on Making Tax Digital covers what flat rate users must keep digitally. On the scheme, digital records of purchases are not required unless they relate to capital items.

You still need to keep:

Invoices to VAT-registered customers still show the normal rate, not the flat rate. Getting the wording right matters, particularly on construction work where the domestic reverse charge can apply, so see our guide to VAT domestic reverse charge invoice wording. For the basics every invoice needs, read UK invoice requirements for tradespeople, and for a wider look at invoicing from site, the field service invoicing guide shows how other mobile trades handle it.

Why the paperwork is the real decision

A lot of the case for the scheme is time saved. You do not need to match every purchase receipt to a VAT figure. That can be real for a sole trader who does admin in the van after a long day.

But the scheme saves time only on one task. You still need to quote, invoice, keep receipts for your tax return and track how each job performs. If you cut your receipt handling because the scheme lets you, you lose the figures you need to decide whether the scheme is still right, and to complete Self Assessment. Keeping clean records is what lets you switch with confidence.

What we think

We built TradeTally around the admin that follows a day on site, so we see this decision as a record-keeping question as much as a VAT one. Whichever method you pick, you need to know what each job earned, what you spent and what you invoiced.

Our advice is to make the choice on numbers, not on the promise of less paperwork. Invoice every job with the right VAT, capture every receipt when you get it, and review a full set of quarterly figures before you join or leave. If your records are in one place, comparing the two methods takes minutes rather than an evening.

That is what we designed TradeTally for: branded invoices, receipt capture from your phone, a live profit view for each job, and tax-ready exports for Self Assessment, all from one app that works on mobile.

Simon

Keep your records ready for either scheme

TradeTally is a UK app for sole tradespeople that brings quotes, invoices, expenses and receipts together, with MTD-ready record-keeping and exports for Self Assessment, including SA103F. The Starter plan is £0 per month and covers limited invoicing. The Professional plan is £12 per month or £120 per year, with unlimited invoices, receipts and tax exports. You can see the plans and start on the pricing page.

Tradetally

If you work as a subcontractor, our CIS invoice software handles CIS deductions on your invoices, and the guide to CIS explains how they interact with your tax.

FAQ

Is the Flat Rate Scheme better than standard VAT?

It depends on how much VAT you pay on purchases. If you buy a fair amount of materials and your flat rate is low, as in the plumber example, the scheme can leave you better off. If you are a limited cost business paying 16.5%, standard VAT is often as good or cheaper. Run both on a recent year of figures.

Do I charge my customers the flat rate?

No. You charge VAT at the normal rate on your invoices. The flat rate is only the percentage you use to work out what you pay HMRC, applied to your VAT-inclusive turnover.

Can I leave the scheme if it is not working?

Yes. You can leave at any time by writing to HMRC, and most businesses leave at the end of an accounting period. You then cannot rejoin for 12 months, so decide carefully.

What is the limited cost trader rate?

It is a flat 16.5% for businesses whose goods spend is under 2% of turnover, or more than 2% but under £1,000 a year. It applies whatever your sector, and it is 15.5% in your first year of VAT registration. Many labour-only trades meet the test.

Sources

Related articles

See all articles